![]() |
|||||||||
|
|
|||||||||
What's the best deal for green electricity? |
||||
|
||||
|
Question: What's the simplest thing you can do to make a large difference to your environmental 'footprint' - the effect your activities have on the environment? Answer: Switch to renewable electricity - it is often as cheap as regular electricity and as easy as making a phone call. You may be able to do this both as an organisation and by encouraging employees to do the same at home. An estimated 60,000 customers have already done so according to Ofgem. You might think that your contribution would be negligible, but by signing up for green electricity, not only would you help to reduce pollution, you would also send a powerful message to electricity companies to invest more in renewable energy technologies. This feature explains how to find the best deal for you, and where to find out more about the supply schemes. What's the best deal for green electricity?Schemes may be evaluated on price and 'green-ness'... Green-nessNot all schemes are as green as each other. For example, electricity which comes from waste-to-energy plants will never be as green as wind energy, as the plants generate some pollution and discourage recycling or reuse. This is shown by the Friends of the Earth league table [below], which puts Unit(e) on top. The table has been compiled using information provided by Greenprices and is based on an interpretation of OFGEM's guidelines for green electricity suppliers. PriceThe large table [below] compares all suppliers and schemes and gives full details. It covers domestic and business deals. but prices vary according to where you are. If you want to find out how much green electricity costs in your area, type in your postcode at: www.greenprices.com/uk/pricesbox.asp, and it give you the offers from different suppliers. You need to know your approximate consumption in a year. Accreditting green powerMost UK green electricity supplies have been vetted and accredited under the Energy Saving Trust's (EST) Future Energy Scheme (see large table). After a period of reconsidering the scheme's future, the EST has announced it will continue. It will accredit green supply schemes in line with Ofgem's recently launched green guidelines. There are two types of offerings accredited by Future Energy:
A guaranteed marketThe Renewables Obligation (and the Scottish Renewables Obligation in Scotland) obliges all electricity suppliers to source a growing percentage of their total supplies from eligible renewable energy sources. It is set at 3% for the year starting from April 2002 and will grow to 10.4 % in 2010. Electricity suppliers will have to prove they have fulfilled the quota through the delivery of Renewable Obligation Certificates (ROCs). These can be bought from renewables generators and will provide additional revenue for them. Suppliers that fail to meet their quota will have to pay 3p for each kWh of electricity below their Obligation. However, by signing up to a Green Tariff customers can help to increase the proportion of green electricity in the supply mix. The third table [below] shows who's buying the most in the UK as of May 2002. A Green Tariff will be over-and-above that required by the Renewables Obligation, as the electricity supplied under a Green Tariff will not be used by the supplier to meet its quota. You can also help to increase the amount of electricity from renewables by signing up to a Green Fund, as the electricity generated by installations built using the Fund should not be eligible for meeting suppliers Renewables Obligation. Need more information on the Renewables Obligation?The following can be found on the Ofgem web site:
Other web resources:
|
||||
Suppliers of renewable electricity and details of their schemessource: NATTA and Future Energy |
|||||||||||
|
Name of Supplier |
Owned By |
Brand Name |
Offer (extra?) |
Type of offering |
CL Exemption? |
Additional to RO? |
Renewable Energy Sources Used |
Areas Covered |
Customer Type |
Use EST? |
Contact No |
|
TXU-Energi |
TXU Europe |
Eco-Power |
5 or 10% Extra |
Supply/ Fund |
N/A |
Yes |
Solar/Wind/Biomass |
National |
Domestic |
Yes |
0800 183 1222 |
|
TXU-Energi |
TXU Europe |
Green Supply |
Site Specific |
Supply |
Yes |
Yes |
Landfill Gas/Wind |
National |
Business |
No |
01234 322 642 |
|
London Electricity |
Electricity de France |
Green Tariff |
£13.20/ annum |
Fund |
N/A |
No |
All Sources |
London Area only |
Domestic |
Yes |
0800 587 4433 |
|
London Electricity |
Electricity de France |
Green Tariff |
Site Specific |
Supply |
Yes |
No |
Energy from Waste |
National |
Business |
No |
0800 587 4433 |
|
npower |
Innogy Holdings |
Juice |
Same Price |
Supply |
Yes |
Yes |
All Sources |
National |
Domestic |
No |
0800 632 632 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Business |
No |
|
|
Northern Ireland Electricity |
N/A |
Eco-Energy |
10, 50 or 100% |
Supply/ |
Yes |
Undecided |
All Sources |
Northern Ireland only |
Domestic |
Yes |
0845 745 5455 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Business |
No |
|
|
PowerGen |
PowerGen UK |
GreenPlan |
4% per annum |
Supply |
N/A |
Yes |
All Sources |
National |
Domestic |
Yes |
0800 015 4244 |
|
PowerGen |
PowerGen UK |
GreenSupply |
Site Specific |
Supply |
Yes |
Yes |
All Sources |
National |
Business |
No |
024 7642 4242 |
|
Renewable Energy Company Ltd. |
N/A |
Ecotricity |
Same Price |
Supply |
Yes |
Yes |
New build wind/solarÊ |
England & Wales |
Business & Domestic |
No |
01453Ê756 111 |
|
SEEBOARD plc |
Central & South West |
Go Green |
£15 per annum |
Fund |
N/A |
Undecided |
All Sources |
SEEBOARD Region Only |
Domestic |
Yes |
0800 581 255 |
|
Scottish & Southern |
N/A |
RSPB Energy |
Same price |
Supply/ |
N/A |
No |
Hydro/Wind/Landfill Gas/SewageGas |
National |
Domestic |
Yes |
0800 028 8552 |
|
ScottishPower |
N/A |
Green Energy |
£14.60/ annum |
Supply |
N/A |
Yes |
Hydro/Wind |
ScottishPower & MANWEB Regions only |
Domestic |
No |
0845 272 7111 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Business |
No |
|
|
SWALEC |
Scottish & Southern |
RSPB Energy |
Same Price |
Supply |
N/A |
No |
Hydro/Tidal/Landfill Gas |
SWALEC Region only |
Domestic |
Yes |
0800 052 123 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Business |
No |
|
|
SWEB |
London Electricity |
Green Tariff |
£13.20 per yr |
Fund |
N/A |
No |
Hydro/Wind/Landfill Gas/ Solar Energy |
National |
Domestic |
Yes |
0800 328 9026 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Business |
No |
|
|
Unit Energy |
Utility Link |
Unit[e] |
15% per annum |
Supply |
Yes |
Yes |
Wind/Hydro |
National |
Domestic |
Yes |
0845 601 1410 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Business |
No |
|
|
Yorkshire Electricity |
npower |
Green Electricity |
£15.60 per yr |
Supply |
N/A |
No |
All Sources |
Mainly Yorkshire Region |
Domestic |
No |
0800 023 045 |
|
Yorkshire Electricity |
npower |
Green Electricity |
Site Specific |
Supply |
Yes (To existing customers only) |
No |
Wind/Biomass |
National |
Business |
No |
0845 722 7733 |
|
Servista.Com |
N/A |
Green Power |
£1 per month |
Supply |
N/A |
Yes |
Wind/Water |
National |
Domestic |
No |
0870 241 2732 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Business |
No |
|
|
Greenenergy (UK) plc |
N/A |
Green Energy |
5% per annum |
Supply |
No |
Yes |
All Sources |
National |
Domestic |
No |
01920 486 156 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Business |
No |
|
Friends of the Earth's green energy league table |
||
|
Rank |
Tariff |
Company |
|
1 |
Unit[e] |
(Unit[e]) |
|
= 2 |
Ecotricity |
(Ecotricity) |
|
= 2 |
Green Energy 100 |
(Green Energy UK) |
|
= 4 |
Eco Energy |
(Northern Ireland Electricity) |
|
= 4 |
Green Energy 10 |
(Green Energy UK) |
|
= 6 |
Juice |
(Innogy Group) |
|
= 6 * |
Ecopower |
(TXU Energi) |
|
= 6 * |
Green Tariff |
(London Electricity Group) |
|
= 9 * |
RSPB Energy |
(Scottish and Southern Energy) |
|
= 9 * |
Green Energy Offer |
(Scottish Power) |
|
11 * |
Green Fund Tariff |
(Seeboard Energy Ltd) |
|
GreenPlan (Powergen) - New product due as we went to press Servista (Servista) - Didn't answer questionnaire. |
||
|
All ranked companies listed above offer energy based tariff unless marked with an asterisk * which indicates a fund based tariffs. Further details, including ranking methodology, available from FoE. |
||
Who's buying the most green power?(Top UK buyers ranked in the top 25 of European purchasers) |
||||
|
Rank |
User |
Quantity/year (million KWhours) |
Supplier |
As proportion of total consumption |
|
2 |
Procter and Gamble UK |
121.5 |
London Electricity |
49 % |
|
3 |
Authorities buying consortium (abc) |
112 |
Scottish Power |
20 % |
|
5 |
London Borough of Lewisham |
55 |
London Energy, SSE and REC |
100 % |
|
8 |
North Wales Energy Partnership |
4.5 |
Scottish Power |
30 % |
|
11 |
NHS Scotland |
33.7 |
Scottish Power |
10 % |
|
12 |
KPMG UK |
31.7 |
London Electricity |
94 % |
|
13 |
Corporation of London |
31.2 |
NUON |
38 % |
|
14 |
TeleCity UK Ltd |
30 |
London Electricity |
100 % |
|
16 |
Greenwich Council |
25.5 |
SSE |
53 % |
|
17 |
Edinburgh University |
25 |
Scottish Power |
42 % |
|
20 |
Cooperative Bank |
20.4 |
Ecotricity |
97 % |
|
22 |
Bodyshop |
15.7 |
Ecotricity |
73 % |
|
25 |
Oxfordshire County Council |
10.2 |
MANWEB |
33 % |
|
[SSE = Scottish and Southern Energy plc. REC = Renewable Energy Co.] |
||||